Padakuu All articles
Suburban Anthropology

Curb Appeal, Five Stars: I Turned My Block's Little Free Libraries Into a Michelin Guide and Started a Turf War

Padakuu
Curb Appeal, Five Stars: I Turned My Block's Little Free Libraries Into a Michelin Guide and Started a Turf War

Photo: Grendelkhan, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Michelin Guide has stars. My neighborhood has wooden boxes on posts. I decided these were the same thing. I printed a rubric. I bought a clipboard. By 9 a.m. I was standing on a curb in a fleece vest, explaining to a golden retriever why the selection at the Cedar Street branch lacked cohesion. The dog was not impressed. The dog was correct.

The Rubric

I rated each Little Free Library on five criteria, 20 points each: Selection, Curb Appeal, Structural Integrity, Vibe, and Amuse-Bouche. Amuse-Bouche is the little thing you find inside that is not a book: a bookmark, a sticker, a grocery list, a pressed flower, a warning. I took this extremely seriously. I made a lanyard. I regret the lanyard.

The Reviews

The Cedar Street Branch — 92/100

A strong contender. The selection was a mix of beach reads, one biography of a president, and a suspiciously good copy of 'The Da Vinci Code' with a grocery list inside. The grocery list was better than the book. Curb appeal: excellent. The box was painted a color I can only describe as 'gentleman's den.' Structural integrity: the door closed with a satisfying click, like a car door in a commercial. Vibe: dentist waiting room, but in a good way. Amuse-Bouche: a bookmark that said 'You're doing great, sweetie.' I kept it. I am not sorry.

The Maple Box — 78/100

The Maple Box is the neighborhood's problematic fave. The hinges were emotionally unavailable. The selection included three John Grisham paperbacks, a romance novel with a cigarette burn, and a cookbook for a cuisine that does not exist. Curb appeal: fine. The box is shaped like a house, which is cute, but the roof is not level. I measured. Structural integrity: the door stuck. Vibe: a yard sale that gave up. Amuse-Bouche: a single loose almond. I did not eat it. I thought about it.

The Box on the Corner of 5th and Nobody Knows — 41/100

This box is a hazard. The structural integrity is that of a wet cardboard box that has seen things. The selection was one VHS of 'Jerry Maguire' and a pamphlet about raccoons. Curb appeal: the curb is more appealing. Vibe: haunted. Amuse-Bouche: a business card for a tax preparer named Gary. I called Gary. Gary said he did not know how the card got there. Gary was nice. Gary gets one star. The box gets 41.

The Little Free Library Formerly Known as a Birdhouse — 88/100

A triumph of adaptive reuse. The selection was small but thoughtful: poetry, a graphic novel, a book about local birds. Curb appeal: excellent. The roofline, however, was off. I brought a level. This was a mistake. Structural integrity: the door was held shut by a magnet and hope. Vibe: a tiny chapel for people who read. Amuse-Bouche: a handwritten note that said 'Take this one, it's better than it looks.' I took it. It was better than it looked.

The Turf War

Here is the thing about reviewing Little Free Libraries: people have feelings. A woman named Donna accused me of 'review-bombing the Maple Box.' I had given it a 78. She said her grandson built it. I said the hinges were emotionally unavailable. She said I was banned. I said I was a critic. She said, 'You're a guy with a clipboard.' Fair.

The Cedar Street branch banned me for 'aggressive note-leaving.' I left a review card that said 'the vibe is giving dentist waiting room.' The Birdhouse banned me for trying to measure the roofline with a level. In my defense, the roofline was off. I was not wrong. I was just banned.

Paperback Economics

Little Free Libraries run on a donation economy that would make an economist weep. The hottest currency is not money. It is the John Grisham paperback. Every box has at least three. No one knows where they come from. They are the cockroaches of the book world, and I mean that with love. The second hottest currency is the book you clearly took from your own shelf and then checked back to see if anyone took it. The third is the book you left because you did not want to throw it away but also did not want to own it. This is how a box ends up with a cookbook for a cuisine that does not exist.

The Warm Finish

Here is what I learned: the boxes are not restaurants. They are tiny acts of faith. The people who stock them are not chefs. They are neighbors who think you might like a book. The best box on my block is not the one with the best selection. It is the one with the most handwritten notes. 'Sorry about the rain.' 'If you took the Grisham, no you didn't.' 'This one made me cry on a Tuesday.' I got banned from three. I got invited to two. Donna and I are fine. She let me back in after I admitted the hinges were fine. They were not fine. But I am learning.

All Articles

Related Articles

The 45-Second Season: I Reviewed Prestige TV Using Only 'Previously On' Recaps and Became Unbearable

The 45-Second Season: I Reviewed Prestige TV Using Only 'Previously On' Recaps and Became Unbearable

Dial M for Maybe: I Called Hollywood's Fake 555 Numbers and Accidentally Built a Friend Group

Dial M for Maybe: I Called Hollywood's Fake 555 Numbers and Accidentally Built a Friend Group

Hands in the Air (I'm at the DMV): My Week Being Hype-Manned Through Existence

Hands in the Air (I'm at the DMV): My Week Being Hype-Manned Through Existence